Evan Peters’ Love Life: From Coachella Romances To On-Set Sparks

  • By Jasmine
  • Jan. 26, 2026, 6 a.m.

The Many Faces of Evan Peters: From Villain to Good Guy

Evan Peters has made quite the name for himself playing complex characters in Ryan Murphy's productions - from the twisted roles in American Horror Story to the chilling portrayal of Jeffrey Dahmer in Monster. But in his latest venture, The Beauty, Peters steps into the shoes of an FBI agent, a switch that has fans buzzing about his off-screen life.

In a 2015 interview, Peters mentioned, "I'm just looking for a girl who gives me a chance," and it seems he's had a fair share of luck since then.

“I'm just looking for a girl who gives me a chance.”

Recent Rumors: Romance with Natalie Engel

Fans have been speculating about Peters' latest romantic escapades, particularly his connection with writer Natalie Engel. Initially spotted sharing a moment at Coachella during Lana Del Rey's set in 2024, the couple soon made it official at a chic Prada event. However, as the rumor mill churns, whispers of their split surfaced this past summer, though neither has publicly confirmed the breakup.

Past Flames: Halsey and Emma Roberts

Before Engel, Peters had a high-profile romance with singer Halsey in 2019. Their relationship became a hot topic after Halsey's now-deleted tweet humorously acknowledged her attraction to Peters' darker roles. The end of their relationship seemed quietly linked to social media activity during the 2020 Black Lives Matter protests.

Even more dramatic was his on-again, off-again relationship with American Horror Story co-star Emma Roberts. The couple's romantic timeline was peppered with public altercations and reconciliations, ultimately ending in 2019 after several tumultuous years.

Evan Peters' dating history is as colorful as his roles, leaving fans eagerly watching to see who will capture his heart next.

Jasmine
Author: Jasmine
Jasmine

Jasmine

Jasmine Kwon covers the wildest headlines out of California — from OnlyFans controversies to late-night celebrity arrests. With roots in Koreatown and a radar for viral chaos, Jasmine is always two steps ahead of the next Hollywood meltdown.