Why The 'Rent' Revival In Madrid Hits A Flat Note

A Legendary Musical Returns

Thirty years ago, Broadway was lit up by the arrival of 'Rent,' a trailblazing musical inspired by the opera 'La Bohème.' This rock-infused narrative brought to life the challenges of young artists in New York City, wrestling with issues like poverty, addiction, HIV, and housing insecurity. Jonathan Larson, the creative force behind this masterpiece, tragically passed away just a day before the show's debut. His work, however, remains an enduring symbol of a generation, transcending its origins to become a beloved classic on stages worldwide and even on the silver screen.

Fast forward to today, and 'Rent' is back on stage, this time at Madrid's Teatro Fernán Gómez. Directed by José Luis Sixto, this revival attempts to breathe new life into the timeless themes of friendship, love, and self-discovery. However, despite its noble intentions, the production seems to have lost some of the original's raw edge.

Missing the Edge

The change in musical arrangement is perhaps the most striking difference. Where the '90s version was a gripping rock anthem, this new rendition opts for softer tones, swapping electric guitars for keyboards. This shift softens the sound but also dilutes the emotional intensity, leaving some scenes feeling overly sweet and more sterile than stirring.

Adding to this, a conspicuous ballet ensemble accompanies the main cast throughout, which dilutes the portrayal of personal struggles by making the stage feel overly crowded. This decision seems to target the TikTok generation more than theatergoers craving genuine emotional engagement.

"'Rent' was written for those unafraid to be different, for seekers of love and freedom despite their fears and setbacks," an observer noted, capturing both the show's spirit and its enduring appeal.

Stage and Sound Challenges

Visually, the production is a spectacle, with lighting that plays masterfully with shadows and gradients, creating a dynamic and bustling stage environment. However, this dynamic can be a distraction, making it tough for some audience members, especially those seated further back, to follow the intricate storyline.

The true magic happens in quieter scenes, where minimal actors on stage allow the performance to breathe and gain emotional depth. Yet, even these moments are undermined by poor acoustics, which often distort lyrics and dialogue, essential elements in a musical where every note carries meaning.

Moments of Brilliance

Despite these setbacks, the production still dazzles in parts. Carla Pulpón, in her role as Maureen, delivers a standout performance, particularly during a protest scene that echoes the spirit of the original. Her commanding presence recalls Idina Menzel's iconic portrayal, yet she adds her own flair, captivating the audience with each note.

The premiere on December 23 drew a full house, and the trend has continued. Even the Spanish royals, King Felipe VI and Queen Letizia, were spotted enjoying the show incognito, adding a touch of royal approval to the event.

A Reflection on Change

While 'Rent' was conceived as a piece to provoke thought and inspire change, this latest iteration, despite its technical finesse, feels a bit too polished and safe to ignite the same fervor. Yet, its ability to fill theaters proves its continued relevance. Just like its debut three decades ago, audiences seek out 'Rent' for insights into life's challenges, even if the answers aren't always handed to them on a silver platter.